Footwear for Arthritic Knees: Are Birkenstocks and Hoka Shoes Good Choices?

Choosing the right footwear is crucial if you have arthritic knees. The right shoes can help reduce pain, improve mobility, and provide the necessary support. As a Physiotherapist, I often get asked about the effectiveness of different types of footwear for managing arthritis symptoms. Specifically, many of my patients wonder if Birkenstocks and Hoka shoes/trainers are good choices. Here’s a detailed look at these popular brands and how they might benefit those with arthritic knees.

Understanding Arthritis and the Importance of Proper Footwear

Arthritis, particularly osteoarthritis in the knees, can cause significant pain, stiffness, and reduced mobility. Proper footwear plays a critical role in managing these symptoms by providing:

• Cushioning: To absorb shock and reduce stress on the knees.
• Support: To maintain proper alignment and distribute weight evenly.
• Stability: To prevent unnecessary movement that could exacerbate pain.

Birkenstocks for Arthritic Knees

Birkenstocks are well-known for their distinctive cork footbeds and supportive design. Here’s how they might benefit those with arthritic knees:

1. Arch Support: Birkenstocks offer excellent arch support, which can help maintain proper foot alignment and reduce stress on the knees.
2. Cushioning: The cork footbed moulds to the shape of your foot over time, providing personalized cushioning and support.
3. Stability: Birkenstocks are designed with a wide base, offering good stability which is crucial for individuals with arthritis.
4. Adjustability: Many Birkenstock models feature adjustable straps, allowing for a customized fit which can help accommodate changes in foot shape due to arthritis.

Considerations:

• Birkenstocks might not provide the same level of cushioning as some athletic shoes, so they may not be suitable for high-impact activities.
• They are better suited for casual wear rather than intensive physical activities.

Hoka Shoes/Trainers for Arthritic Knees

Hoka shoes are renowned for their maximalist design, featuring thick soles and superior cushioning. Here’s why they might be a good choice for those with arthritic knees:

1. Cushioning: Hoka shoes are known for their excellent cushioning, which can absorb impact and reduce stress on the knees.
2. Lightweight Design: Despite their thick soles, Hoka shoes are surprisingly lightweight, reducing the effort required to move.
3. Support and Stability: Many Hoka models provide good arch support and a stable base, essential for managing knee pain.
4. Rocker Sole Design: The curved sole design of Hoka shoes promotes a natural gait cycle, which can help reduce knee strain.

Considerations:

• The high level of cushioning might take some time to get used to, especially if you are transitioning from less cushioned footwear.
• Hoka shoes can be more expensive, but the investment can be worthwhile for the comfort and support they provide.

LEARN MORE ABOUT HOW I CAN HELP YOU REGAIN CONTROL OVER YOUR KNEE. CLICK HERE.

Tips for Choosing the Right Footwear for Arthritic Knees

1. Fit is Key: Ensure your shoes fit well, with enough room for your toes and no tight spots.
2. Try Before You Buy: Whenever possible, try on shoes and walk around in them to ensure they provide the comfort and support you need.
3. Consult Your Physiotherapist: Discuss your footwear choices with your Physiotherapist to ensure they meet your specific needs and conditions.
4. Regularly Check Your Shoes: Over time, even the best shoes can wear out and lose their supportive features. Regularly check and replace them as needed.

Other Options

Birkenstocks and Hoka shoes might give good support but there are plenty of other makes out there that use the same design principles and get equally good results. I don’t find Birkenstocks comfortable but I do look for a shoe with similarly shaped moulding, however many of my patients love them and if they are comfy they will give you great support. On the trainer front, I like Asics and New Balance as I find they give my foot good support. As yet I have not tried Hoka but based on feedback from clinic I would give them a try.

Conclusion

Both Birkenstocks and Hoka shoes/trainers can be good choices for individuals with arthritic knees, each offering unique benefits. Birkenstocks provide excellent arch support and stability for everyday wear, while Hoka shoes offer superior cushioning and support for more active lifestyles. The key is to choose the footwear that best fits your lifestyle and provides the necessary support and comfort. Always consult with your healthcare provider to ensure your footwear choice is appropriate for your specific condition.

P.S. Struggling with an arthritic knee? I would love to help you better manage and regain control over your knee. Click to find out more.

Take care, Helen

Helen Manders BSc (Hons) MCSP HCPC

Chartered Physiotherapist Since 2001